Home » Book review »History » Currently reading:

Unhappy anniversary: Tacoma expelled Chinese 125 years ago

January 22, 2010 | Category: Book review, History

138  320x240 anit chinese riot seattle Unhappy anniversary: Tacoma expelled Chinese 125 years ago At 9:30 a.m. on Nov. 3, 1885, a mob of several hundred men marched through Tacoma’s Chinese community, rousting its last 200 residents and herding them nine miles south to the Lake View train station, in what is now Lakewood, as policemen and sheriff’s deputies looked on. After spending a cold, rainy night, many in partly open outbuildings, the Chinese were forced onto trains bound for Portland.

Chinese workers were instrumental in the construction of the nation’s transcontinental railroads in the 1860s and ’70s. By the early 1880s, however, the major railroad lines were nearing completion, and Chinese laborers were moving to the cities of the West to find other work, according to Ed Echtle, a Pacific Northwest historian specializing in Asian immigration. As other immigrant groups arrived from Europe, the competition for labor intensified. Unions began to organize unskilled workers and tapped into their aversion to the Chinese.

Anti-Chinese discrimination became federal policy in 1882 when Congress passed the Chinese Exclusion Act, the first U.S. immigration law designed to bar a specific nationality.

The Chinese became kind of a scapegoat for low wages because they were charged with working for less, undercutting white labor,” Echtle said. “And then in the 1880s there was an economic downturn, which sort of exacerbated things, so that the Exclusion Act was a political response to the pressure from constituents to ban unskilled Chinese labor from coming in to compete with white labor.

Yet, it was not all about labor and wages: Newspapers at the time alluded to foreign heathenism, to rats and squalor in the Chinese sections of towns, to foul smells that nauseated patrons at neighboring white businesses, to opium use and prostitution. A spark was being struck, and many Tacomans – from underemployed railroad and mill workers to smug storekeepers and social-climbing politicos – were eager to grab torches.

On Sept. 28, at an anti-Chinese rally in Seattle, it was resolved that the Chinese had to get out of Washington Territory by Nov. 1, and white-owned businesses were called upon to dismiss their Chinese employees. In Tacoma, where only a few people (Washington pioneer Ezra Meeker was one) spoke out against the agitators or defied their demands to fire their Chinese workers, about 450 Chinese boarded trains or ships or left by other means; the remaining 200 were marched out to Lake View on Nov 4. Historian Murray Morgan in his book “Puget’s Sound” described the procession: “Teamsters cracked their whips, the wagons lurched forward. The elderly and the sick Chinese were permitted to ride. The rest trudged after the wagons, wrapped in blankets against the cold rain, duffle slung on poles over their shoulders or in laundry bags on their backs. Their sandals sucked mud; some took them off and went barefoot. Many were crying. Armed whites on horseback rode beside the refugees, herding them like cattle, and a guard of club-carrying whites brought up the rear, urging on the stragglers.”

They spent a miserable night, some in the station waiting room, where there was a single stove, others in freight sheds. According to Jules Alexander Karlin in a 1954 article in Pacific Historical Review the Chinese would maintain that the ordeal drove one woman, a merchant’s wife, insane, and that two of their number later died from their prolonged exposure to the weather.

Two days later, arsonists set fire to the vacated Chinese shops and dwellings of Little Canton. Tacoma’s Chinese community was effectively erased.

* * * * *

139  320x240 driven out cover Unhappy anniversary: Tacoma expelled Chinese 125 years ago Tacoma was by no means the only American city to evict its Chinese residents; in fact, as University of Delaware professor Jean Pfaelzer reveals in her book “Driven Out: The Forgotten War Against Chinese Americans” (hardcover published by Random House in 2007; paperback published by University of California Press in 2008), there were nearly 200 expulsions of Chinese populations from American communities in the American West and Northwest from the early 1850s to 1906.

White Protestant nativists – as well as immigrants whom the nativists vilified – were vocal in their objections to Chinese living in their midst, even as the latter were helping to build the railroads, working as launderers and domestics and laboring in mines, in canneries, in logging camps and on ranches. Notes Pfaelzer, “The white man’s racial rhetoric was, in fact, about himself: the Chinese worked too many hours; the Chinese worker was drugged on opium; the Chinese worker was slovenly; the Chinese debased the town and created the need for civic jobs; the Chinese ate rats; the Chinese were renters; the Chinese lived in overcrowded housing; the Chinese demanded the right to own property; the Chinese were expected to send scarce money back to their homeland. The Chinese were also derided as “sojourners,” people with unbreakable ties with their empire across the ocean and incapable of assimilating and becoming good, loyal American citizens – even if white Americans would have them. The assaults on life, liberty and property that resulted from this mind-set ranged from the spontaneous to the systematic: from armed gangs of resentful white prospectors evicting their Chinese counterparts from the California gold fields, to average citizens joining in boycotts to deprive their resident “celestials” of their livelihoods.

For example, in Eureka, Calif., in early 1885, an unfortunate incident in which a city councilman was shot to death during a dispute between two Chinese turned into an excuse for vigilantes to round up more than 300 Chinese residents, imprison them in warehouses, then force them onto ships bound for San Francisco. The eviction conducted in Washington Territory in November of that year would follow Eureka’s model.

By contrast, in late 1885 and early 1886, the white citizens of Truckee, Calif., sought a more peaceful means of expulsion by boycotting Chinese businesses and those that employed Chinese workers. Never mind the fact that Truckee’s Chinese were “renters, shoppers, and low-paid laborers, and white agents made money from their legal, real estate, and commercial transactions,” and that “seemingly, this interracial relationship benefited everyone,” writes Pfaelzer: The so-called Truckee Method, while slower than the Eureka Method, achieved the same goal.

Pfaelzer’s scholarship is exemplary, not just because it reveals that expulsions of Chinese were common exercises in ethnic cleansing – rather than just a few isolated incidents – in small towns and large over a period of more than 50 years, but because most of this information was there all along for the sifting, in newspaper accounts and public documents. No newly uncovered treasure trove of documents, no long-buried diaries suddenly brought to light: Rather, Pfaelzer took what others missed and added an essential and long-overdue chapter to our nation’s past.

But Pfaelzer gives us much more than a litany of shameful events: She shows that beleaguered Chinese were willing to stand up for themselves by using the legal system to sue for reparations, by testifying to the injustices that they were subjected to, by striking for fair wages and refusing to supply goods to hostile businesses – even purchasing arms to defend their homes and their lives. Certainly, the Chinese understood the rights and duties that American citizenship entailed; what they were denied was the paperwork that would give them that legal status.

Purchase Driven Out: The Forgotten War against Chinese Americans Unhappy anniversary: Tacoma expelled Chinese 125 years ago

Currently there is "1 comment" on this Article:

  1. Kevin Mckenna says:

    A very interesting take on an easily forgotten past. Looks to be an excellent read.

Comment on this Article:




Yesterday's Gallery

Visit SportsCollectingNews.com

Palmer Wirfs - America's Largest Antique & Collectible Shows

Foss Waterway Seaport

Timothy Hughes Rare & Early Newspapers

Visiti website

Dietrich's Vault

Prize Fighting Books

Curtright and Son Tribal Art

Visit the Fred Oldfield Western Heritage & Art Center

Visit Scripophily.com

Visit Railroad Memories website

Facebook activity

Sign up for our mailing list.

AbeBooks - Signed Books

Exclusive interviews

Real Deal‘: A new show for real collectors … especially ones who want to make a fast buck


~An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive~ Yard sale speculators, eBay entrepreneurs, garage sale gamblers – you read it here first: There’s a new show just for you! It’s called “Real Deal,” and it premieres on …

Collector spotlight: Robert L. Shapiro

Robert L. Shapiro photo courtesy of Robert Shapiro

~ An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive ~ . In a recent post (“The real deal: AmeriCollector is trademarked,” Aug. 19) I joked about getting our trademark with the help of “our high-profile …

King of pawn: Rick Harrison of ‘Pawn Stars’ talks about the shop and collecting


~ An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive ~ . It’s no secret that I’m a huge fan of “Pawn Stars” on the History Channel (or HISTORY, as they prefer to be called). It …

Johnny be there! Guitars are in the mix at Christie’s musical instruments auction April 29


~ An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive ~ . For those looking to invest in the vintage guitar market, now may be a great time to do so: The market peaked at the …

Restoration angels: The History Channel’s ‘American Restoration’ premieres April 15


~ An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive ~ . April 15: a date that always reminds me of death, taxes, and collecting … and whether money owed to the IRS will put a …

Chicago and beyond: Art Shay photo exhibition features 60 years of unforgettable moments


~ An AmeriCollector.com Exclusive ~ . A buff and smiling yet self-conscious-looking Marlon Brando, age 26, relaxes on his Libertyville, Ill., farm in the company of his spaniel, that steadiest …

Ben Isitt: The evil genius behind the scenes at the Black Lake Haunted Asylum

Ben Isitt

“Those lab specimens … those body parts … Are they REAL?” You may well be asking yourself that if you work up the courage to show up during “visiting hours” …

Calalogs received

Catalog received: Books in dust jackets from Babylon Revisited

14 Mar 2012

I always enjoy browsing a new catalog from Babylon Revisited, a bookseller we’ve profiled before (“You CAN judge a book by its jacket – or, rather, its dust jacket,” in …

‘Collector’s items’

15 Aug 2011

AUCTIONS Railroad memorabilia (closes Fri., Aug. 26, at 5 p.m. MDT). Auction Catalog 80 features more than 500 individual lots. This is the auction that serious railroad buffs watch for …

Catalogs received

25 Jul 2011

AUCTIONS American History (closes Aug. 1). Cowan’s Auctions, Cowanauctions.com Autographs (closes Aug. 10). RRAuction, RRauction.com . BOOKS, ETC. Fifty Rare Works in Science, Medicine and Thought (Catalog 40): Featuring classic …

American Pickers | Shop History Channel


American Pickers | Shop History Channel

150th Anniversary of the American Civil War